Thursday, March 30, 2017

Stanley's Famous Pit Bar-B-Q - Tyler

Stanley’s Famous Pit BBQ proclaims that they are the “Oldest Mom & Pop Joint in Tyler.”  JD Stanley originally opened this joint in 1958 and the barbecue tradition continues today through the efforts of owner Nick Pencis.  Over the past 60 years, Stanley’s barbecue has indeed become famous throughout the state, but they bring even more to the table than just dependable barbecue.

I have been first in line at Stanley’s a few times. This did not take any planning or much of a time investment as I showed up between 10:30 and 10:45 and happily found no one else in line.  However, if you show up after the 11AM lunchtime opening, you are guaranteed to see a line quickly swell and begin to wrap around the building.  My adage that waiting for the doors to open is better than waiting in line seems even more applicable at Stanley’s.


Stanley’s makes it easy if you are a sampler like me.  The menu features the typical one-meat and two-meat meals, but also offers a brilliant “Four Meat Sampler Plate” that delivers all meat and no sides.

Meats at Stanley's Famous in Tyler
When the Four Meat Sampler isn't enough, go on and throw some sausage on too.

Any order should begin with the brisket, which is the best meat of the bunch.  A sign at the walk-up counter encourages customers to be specific with what kind of brisket they would like, citing options as lean, fatty, end cut, extra bark, or no bark. If you order "no bark", you’re crazy. Stanley’s standard cut offers a substantial crust with a bit of crispiness. The meat itself is perfectly moist with noticeable smoke. The simple rub emphasizes the magic of smoke on meat.  The moist cuts are well rendered and the lean cuts feature a nice sliver of rendered fat for an extra injection of flavor.

The ribs at Stanley’s are baby backs and rely more on the seasoning than the brisket does. These ribs are rubbed, glazed and sticky. The meat is soft and offers a perfectly enjoyable texture. However, much of the flavor is derived from the sweet glaze and while they are well prepared, the final product is just too sweet for my taste.

Brisket and Ribs at Stanley's BBQ
A standard two meat plate at Stanley's

Stanley’s turkey is high quality. The cuts are thick and juicy. The flavor balances a smokiness with plenty of black pepper. This bird is done just about as well as you can do it.

The sausage is a solid entry on Stanley’s menu. It features a bit of familiar peppery spice. The links are well prepared with snappy casing. The sausage is typically sliced (unless otherwise specified) before it’s plated for your enjoyment.

Stanley's Famous Pit BBQ
The Texas Trinity at Stanley's
As is the case in many other Texas barbecue joints, the pulled pork here is unremarkable. There is a bit of bark in the moist pile, but there is not much smoke to be found. The notes are appropriately of the vinegary variety, but this is really just your standard take on the meat.


There are a variety of meaty sandwiches which the locals adore. Though I typically overlook this section of most barbecue menus, Stanley’s list is so extensive, it begs for attention. 

And since the praises of “The Mother Clucker” sandwich have so frequently rung in my ears, I finally had to try it. And, oh, am I glad I did.  The Mother Clucker is a beautiful monstrosity that features smoked chicken, cheddar cheese, a fried egg, and spicy mayonnaise served on jalapeƱo cheese sourdough bread (guacamole and candied bacon can be added if you really want to endulge).  A peppery spiciness provides the heft of the flavor on the chicken which meets the spiciness of mayonnaise and melts all together with the oozy egg. The sourdough bread is pillow soft and provides a perfect palette for one of the best sandwiches you will ever have.

The Mother Clucker at Stanley's BBQ
The "Mother Clucker" is a cluckin' good sandwich
Along with sandwiches, you will also find tacos the menu.  This includes breakfast tacos, which along with breakfast sandwiches and breakfast bowls fill the morning menu which is served from 7AM – 10AM.

The sides at Stanley’s are classics. You can choose from beans, a mustard based potato salad, and cole slaw. They are traditional takes on the classics, but are far better than the Sysco products so many barbecue restaurants rely on.

Though the sauce at Stanley’s is unnecessary, they offer two solid varieties. I’m a big fan of the spicy version, even if I only use it on my bread. The spicy sauce has a satisfying peppery bite similar to Rudy’s famous sauce.

Stanley's Famous Pit BBQ in Tyler, Texas
Stanley's unassuming building has a great patio connected to it.

Breakfast, lunch, or dinner – there is not a bad time to go to Stanley’s Famous. But it’s more fun at night.  Six nights a week, the enclosed patio is home to live music and the coolest nightlife in Tyler.  The back patio also features a full bar featuring craft beer (including Tyler’s own True Vine) and the biggest selection of whiskeys, bourbons, and ryes in East Texas. Stanley's also offers whiskey tasting flights if you are so inclined. What better way to complement the "meat flight" a Sampler Plate delivers?


Stanley’s Famous Pit Barbecue is well deserving of the praise that is heaped upon it. These guys are setting the standard for barbecue in East Texas – the brisket is especially wonderful and you should not overlook “The Mother Clucker” as a lunchtime option.  Owner Nick Pencis has not rested on the fact that Stanley’s is considered the benchmark for good barbecue in East Texas, he has also seen to it that Stanley’s sets the standard for good times in East Texas.

Address: 525 S Beckham Ave, Tyler, TX 75702
Phone:  903-539-0311
Hours: Monday – Saturday: 11AM – 10PM (Breakfast: Monday – Friday: 7AM – 10AM)

*All Grades Are Based Solely on the Quality of Texas BBQ Offered at the Joint. We Aren't Looking for Burgers or Catfish!

My Grading Scale:

A = This is some of the finest BBQ you'll find anywhere. It is worth a roadtrip in itself along with any required wait.
B = This is very good BBQ, even if it is over an hour away, consider making the drive.
C = This is just average BBQ but it's worth a stop in a pinch.
D = This is a poor example of Texas BBQ. Even if it's the only place around, skip it. Apologize to any non-Texans that have eaten here.
F = This is not only a bad Texas BBQ, it is probably not suitable for human consumption.

BBQ Reviews, Barbecue, Barbeque, Texas BBQ, "Best BBQ in Texas", Best BBQ in Metroplex, Best BBQ in Austin, Brisket, Sausage, Ribs, Pork Ribs, Beef Ribs, "Best Brisket", Barbecue Blog, Barbecue Rating, Lockhart, Luling, Smoked Meat, Smoked Ribs, Smoke...Hey! Stop reading this!